Is actually Queen Age II Most Pertaining to Prophet Muhammad?

An interesting claim regarding origins out of The girl Majesty King E II has recently surfaced on the internet. Off reliable development offer to day-after-day newspapers, individuals bodies had been debating, critiquing and examining the idea that the Queen try originated from the new Muslim Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Here is what you should know.


The initial registered idea away from Queen Elizabeth’s reference to Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) originates from genealogist Harold B. Brooks-Baker from inside the 1986. From inside the a page in order to following British Finest Minister frustrated moves in the the latest veins of Queen” which he considered common knowledge among Muslim management. This claim keeps wide effects due to the fact, in case it is real, it might in addition to make King a connection of King Mohammed VI out-of Morocco and you will Queen Abdullah II out-of Jordan too since Ali Khamenei, the latest Best Leader of Iran.

Resurgence of your own claim

From inside the , writing from inside the a blog post having Moroccan newsprint Assahifa Al-Ousboue, Abdelhamid Al-Aouni offered Brooks-Baker and advertised your Queen’s descent is going to be traced right back 43 years into Prophet depending on the following the ancestry:

– Allegedly, Abu al-Qasim Muhammed ibn Abbad, a great descendant of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), was the good-parent of Zaida away from Seville.

– Zaida, an excellent Muslim refugee whom escaped the newest Berber pushes within the Seville, went along to the fresh new court out-of Alfonso VI out of Castille in which she turned into his concubine and soon after, his spouse.

– A couple of many years after, the descendent, Isabella out of Castille, partnered the first Duke from York, Edmund Langley and you may offered delivery to help you Richard away from Conisburgh, Earl off Cambridge. He later on fathered Richard Plantagenet, Duke from York, who is aren’t considered a predecessor of your Queen.

Asking the professionals

Brooks-Baker try the publishing manager getting Burke’s Peerage Limited, a great genealogical guide of some 200 years standing dedicated to evaluating the latest origins out-of United kingdom royals and you may nobility.

not, his revelations possess often been disregarded given that purposefully controversial and you may outlandish to get to results the same as today’s clickbait statements . Within his 2005 obituary, Brooks-Baker is also known as an effective “self-designated expert into the the things royal” exactly who “are commonly completely wrong” and when turned-out proper, try merely guilty of and also make noticeable states. The new Telegraph also reported that, diverging off their unprejudiced position regarding rumblings when you look at the this new press, Buckingham Castle provided an announcement so you can explain that Brooks-Baker realized no friends, hence his declarations have been made without studies or authority. The changing times reported that “officials is know to have paid down absolutely nothing notice in earlier times” into states produced by Brooks-Baker.

Uk historian David Starkey says that the “gothic monarchs out-of Spain and also the Islamic regal domiciles have been extremely close” and you can, in one, “interilies” was preferred through the records. That it careful response understands the potential for this new King getting relevant into the Prophet (PBUH) and won’t externally denounce it. Although not, it is not are research.

Meanwhile, Lesley Hazleton, a scholastic and copywriter exactly who is targeted on religion and you may government and you may is recognized as a professional to your Islam, evaluations it as “clickbait.” Predicated on Hazleton, the new claim is simply response to this new “demonisation away from Islam from the West” which ultimately shows a promise that “respectability” is accorded with the faith.

Historians and you will genealogists plus dispute new historic accuracies where the latest claim is built. So it claims sleeps towards the idea that Zaida of Seville try the latest dmed ibn Abbad, which, consequently, is descended regarding Prophet (PBUH). Yet not, Zaida’s own root is questionable due to the fact particular believe, in place of are Abu al-Qasim’s dily.

Adopting the 2012 advancement from Richard III’s remains in a vehicle playground into the Leicester, various genetic examination was basically conducted on the Plantagenet Queen. Previous research has lead for the concern his relation to the fresh new King, indicating she does not appear away from your and this, by the extension, can’t be a beneficial descendant of your Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).

Of numerous has pointed out that “for folks who trace anybody’s ancestry straight back much sufficient, you will find – wonder headache – we’re all connected with each other fundamentally.” – which means that there is certainly an improvement ranging from getting myself descended regarding someone or just are pertaining to her or him. New Observer tries to lay that it from inside the position because of the exhibiting you to definitely a kid born from inside the 1947, could have got 1,024 ninth-grandparents: evaluate it into the Queen, who is alleged to function as the 43 rd great-granddmad (PBUH). Supposing that the holds true, the King might have hundreds of thousands of 43 rd great-grand-parents.

And thus which have openings when you look at the historic facts with no genetic proof, it is difficult to show the loved ones anywhere between a keen 11 th -century Muslim little princess and you will an effective 20 th -100 years British King, never notice a 7 th -century Prophet.